Canon Lens Recommendations
I've held off asking this here because there’s tons of generic lens advice on the internet and it’s too hard to describe what I’m looking for to get specific advice (because frankly I don’t really know). Anyway, I currently have two lenses – one a Canon EF 18-55mm IS 3.5-5.6 lens, it’s what I use almost exclusively. The other is a Tamron 55-200 f4-5.6 which I use when I need the extra zoom but largely ignore because it takes noticeably inferior shots. I also find that 55mm is just a bit too much zoom for a lot of the holiday shots I want to fire off quickly so I miss a lot if I have the bigger zoom lens on my camera.
I don’t really do well with inside shots at the moment – a faster lens (or some off-camera lighting and associated expertise) would be handy for that.
So my choice seems to be between:
- get a better quality zoom of about the same range as the Tamron with image stabilizing so the zoom is a bit more useful, higher quality and particular a bit better in low light situations where the Tamron struggles.
- get a lens somewhere in the middle – I saw a Cannon lens that went from 28mm-135mm somewhere which would fit the range of zoom I use really nicely and would be a handy all purpose lens.
- get one of the “nifty fifty” type prime lenses, which tend to be nice and fast and work well for the general indoor with people doing stuff kind of shots.
Or possibly there’s something else I should be considering… There’s way too many options out there.

June 11th, 2009 at 1:32 am
AJ,
I’ve got a Pentax dSLR, so I can’t recommend any specific Canon lenses in that regard, but I just wanted to agree that “something in the middle” is best for a camera you want to travel with or generally just be all-purpose. I had an 18-55 to start with but it seemed too limiting, so I went for the Pentax 18-250. It’s fantastic–I don’t have to change lenses most of the time (I only switch it with my nifty 50, which is much faster and useful for indoor shots/portraiture/etc), so I don’t have to worry about getting dust on the sensor from lens changes or missing a shot because I don’t have the right zoom. The shots seem to have the same image quality as the 18-55 as well, except for at the very end of the zoom range.
As for Canon lenses in particular, I’m pretty happy with the 28-105 on my Canon 300D film SLR. It gives you a good amount of zoom without sacrificing image quality, but I can’t comment too much on it because I use it exclusively with film, so I take significantly less photos!
June 11th, 2009 at 3:25 am
I love the prime!
http://juliusdavies.ca/photos/D40/2009-05-30-at-mabels/masutani/DSC_1987.JPG
That’s a 35mm F/1.8 Nikon. I could never get the nice blurry background until I bought this. I think Canon has a 50mm F/1.8 with autofocus for around $100 USD brand new. There are several groups on Flickr devoted to the Canon lens, for example:
http://www.flickr.com/groups/873614@N24/
June 11th, 2009 at 8:04 am
So it seems I want both the 28-135 and a nifty fifty. Not sure I can swing that as one birthday present but we’ll see….